In short

Thailand's manufacturing exports rely on the output of very few companies. At the Real-Economy Dialogue that the Joint Foreign Chambers of Commerce in Thailand (JFCCT) held in Bangkok on Wednesday October 14th, The World Bank Group proposed that the Thailand Board of Investment (BOI) make its top incentives conditional on spillovers that can be checked, and claw them back if the targets aren't met. If implemented, BOI-promoted companies would need to change their business strategy to make sure they meet the requirements. The same day, the JFCCT made the case on the rules and regulations side. Below Thailand's laws sit more than 14,000 secondary rules and more than 50,000 internal agency guidelines, on top of laws that are out-of-date, and there is still no permanent office to review them.

The share of mid-size manufacturers that export fell from 26.3% to 12.6%

Dr. Csilla Lakatos, Senior Economist at World Bank Thailand, presented the numbers. Foreign-owned companies are 0.8% of manufacturers in Thailand and account for 63.9% of manufacturing exports, and the share of medium-sized manufacturers (51 to 200 employees) that export at all fell from 26.3% in 2012 to 12.6% in 2022. Thai SME law also uses revenue to define a medium-size manufacturer, with a range of 100m to 500m THB. The census figures here use employee numbers.

The Bank used the Thai industrial census for both figures in its new report, "Building Thailand's Future Today". It launched the report at the Bangkok Business Summit on September 3rd, with Thailand's goal of becoming a high-income country by 2037 in view. The fall in export participation also affected large manufacturers, those with 201 or more employees. Their share fell sharply from 49.5% to 28.9% over the same ten years, a decline she specifically drew attention to. Foreign-owned firms account for 15.3% of manufacturing jobs and 29.3% of fixed assets in the same census. These firms are few in number, yet produce most of Thailand's manufacturing exports.

Thailand's manufacturing exports rely on the output of very few companies.

FEW SMALL FIRMS EXPORT, AND EXPORT PARTICIPATION HAS DECLINED SINCE 2012 Percent of number of firms 2012 2022 0.1 0.1 Micro 2.5 1.8 Small 26.3 12.6 Medium 49.5 28.9 Large Source: World Bank, Building Thailand's Future Today (2026), presented by Csilla Lakatos at the JFCCT Real-Economy Dialogue, Bangkok, October 14th 2026, slide 7. Data: Thai Industrial and Business Census. Manufacturing size classes: micro 1-5, small 6-50, medium 51-200, large 201+ employees.
FOREIGN-OWNED FIRMS ANCHOR MANUFACTURING EXPORTS Foreign-owned firms, percent of total, 2022 Manufacturing Services 0.8 0.4 # of firms 15.3 1.6 Jobs 25.1 3.6 Sales 26.5 3.6 Value added 29.3 1.8 Fixed assets 63.9 Exports 27.1 1.4 Investment Redesign BOI incentives Condition top-tier incentive bands on verifiable spillover metrics, with a clawback clause. Deepen investment linkages Remodel BUILD to follow Singapore's Local Industry Upgrading Programme, with expanded funding. Source: World Bank, Building Thailand's Future Today (2026), presented by Csilla Lakatos at the JFCCT Real-Economy Dialogue, Bangkok, October 14th 2026, slide 8. Data: Thai Industrial and Business Census, 2022. Services: no exports figure on the slide.

What BOI changes did the World Bank propose?

Dr. Lakatos proposed that the BOI make its highest level of incentives conditional on measurable spillovers and recover the incentives if the conditions aren't met. The clawback would cover the tax and non-tax benefits granted under the BOI promotion. She also called for more funding for BUILD, the BOI's supplier matching unit, and for it to be remodeled on Singapore's Local Industry Upgrading Programme.

I'd posted that morning about mid-size suppliers, and about support that rewards companies for growing rather than for their size. The census shows a fall in the share of those manufacturers that export.

I previously developed the strategy for a regional headquarters to obtain additional BOI promotion certificates. The case covered tax, logistics, cash flow and treasury. With a spillover condition and a clawback, finance would also have wanted to know what the BOI would measure, how long we had to meet the targets, and who would decide whether we'd met them and on what basis.

Smaller firms are 75% of Thai goods exporters and 12% of export value

Dr. Lakatos wasn't alone. Dr. Kirida Bhaopichitr, Vice Minister for Commerce, said in her opening keynote speech that micro, small and medium firms represent 75% of Thailand's goods exporters, but only 12% of the export value in 2025, which is the tier a spillover condition is meant to grow. She wants trade to move from "Sell To" to "Sell With", as her slide put it, developing products and markets together with trading partners.

Slide: micro, small and medium enterprises are 75% of Thailand's goods exporters but 12% of merchandise export value in 2025. Source: Dr. Kirida Bhaopichitr, Vice Minister for Commerce, JFCCT Real-Economy Dialogue.

Kobkarn Wattanavrangkul, Chairperson of Toshiba Thailand, gave her comments as a Thai partner of Japanese investors. A Thai supplier may not be the cheapest or meet your requirement today; however, with help, it could next year. She said spillover from her Japanese partners used to come automatically, and that the next generation of investment will need input from the BOI, local government, global markets and end users. She also drew on the positive lessons from decades of Japanese investment in Thailand.

Prof. Dr. Pavida Pananond of Thammasat Business School gave the day's closing perspective on building suppliers that lead firms cannot replace and reminded us that multinationals aren't here as philanthropists. Her core message was resilience. She put the test as a question. What company couldn't the paint maker Jotun live without in Thailand? That, she said, is what would keep Jotun here. She compared Thailand's subsidies, incentives and tax breaks with New Zealand Trade and Enterprise, where a small firm has to perform to qualify for support. She also questioned how often Thailand declares itself a hub for another industry without having a real advantage in it. Her Implications slide said "Know what we are good at. Become indispensable at it."

Slide: implications for policymakers, investors and chambers, ending 'Know what we are good at. Become indispensable at it.' Source: Prof. Dr. Pavida Pananond, Thammasat Business School, JFCCT Real-Economy Dialogue.

The clawback depends on who does the checking

Whether the spillover-and-clawback scheme works will come down to who does the checking. That was the ground of the afternoon panel, "OECD, Integrity, Good Governance and Rule of Law enhancing Investment", with Vibeke Lyssand Leirvag (JFCCT Chairwoman), Dr. Supareak Charlie Chomchan (JFCCT Vice Chair) and Bob Fox (Chair of the JFCCT Digital Economy/ICT Committee and JFCCT Policy Co-Ordinator), and Delphine Schantz of the United Nations Office on Drugs and Crime moderating.

Dr. Supareak described where fast-track regulatory reform, known as the regulatory guillotine, began. Thai business groups paid for the platform, the government paid for the people, and the Thailand Development Research Institute (TDRI) processed over 1,000 procedures, regulations and laws that burden businesses. Thailand is now in its fourth round, though there is little progress to show for it. The political will, budget and machinery of the first round haven't been there in the later ones.

He said the work covers more than 900 primary laws, over 14,000 pieces of secondary legislation and over 50,000 internal guidelines and instructions used by government agencies. Given the silo set-up that the Thai government is hampered with, where will the ownership and accountability lie to achieve this? The government wants Thailand to become a member of the Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD) by 2028, and some 26 committees work on the accession roadmap. Asked by the moderator whether Thailand could meet the 2028 target, he said he didn't think it could. He believes the agencies will have to keep working towards accession because their pay and promotions will depend on it.

Dr. Lakatos presented Thailand's score for administrative and regulatory burden on the OECD's product market regulation (PMR) index: 3.1, against an OECD average of 1.7. A score of 0 is the most competition-friendly on this index; 6 is the least. Completing the regulatory guillotine is also among the Bank's recommendations.

Whether the spillover-and-clawback scheme works will come down to who does the checking.

THAILAND'S REGULATIONS ARE LESS COMPETITION-FRIENDLY THAN THE OECD'S PMR index, 0 = most to 6 = least competition-friendly, 2025 OECD average Thailand Overall PMR 1.3 2.4 Administrative and regulatory burden 1.7 3.1 Barriers in service and network sectors 1.6 2.3 Barriers to trade and investment 0.5 2.2 Distortions induced by public ownership 1.2 1.6 Source: World Bank, Building Thailand's Future Today (2026), presented by Csilla Lakatos at the JFCCT Real-Economy Dialogue, Bangkok, October 14th 2026, slide 5. Data: OECD Product Market Regulation database.

When I was Vice Chairman of JFCCT, from 2011 to 2017, the chambers worked on ease of doing business and on the regulatory guillotine (2016 to 2019), which set out to clear old laws, some of them more than 100 years old. How far it goes depends on political will.

The JFCCT has been asking the government for a permanent office with its own budget and staff, working on this day in, day out. Robert Fox made the rule-of-law case. Genuine public hearings and consultation are what make quality laws. Then the whole system of laws needs continual maintenance. He referred to the permanent law reform commissions in Commonwealth countries. These commissions have enough authority that an individual minister cannot undermine their work. They look at all sides of an issue, including the evidence on law, society, policy and the economy.

Vibeke Lyssand Leirvag said investors consider more than tax incentives when deciding where to invest. They also look at how openly business is done and whether the rules apply equally to companies once they're operating in the country.

Before they can commit with confidence, investors need to know what rules to expect and see them applied equally. A clawback would ensure companies are meeting their obligations for the incentives they are receiving.

No company needs to wait for the government to ask for it.

What I would do next

If I were a foreign investor putting together a BOI application this year, I would proactively plan for Thai suppliers. They would be clearly identified in the business case: company name, what products they would produce, how much spending would go to them and which department in our company would be responsible for the figures. For mid-size manufacturers, I'd be using Pavida Pananond's question: what does my company supply that the firm buying from us couldn't replace us for? No company needs to wait for the government to ask for it. JFCCT's Dr. Supareak put the internal guidelines alone at more than 50,000. That work needs a fast-track structure with the resources to carry it out, and a permanent office to run it.

Whether to pursue BOI promotion for a new operation is part of the work on establishing in Thailand at HundredEast, the independent advisory firm Marc Spiegel founded in Bangkok.