For anyone watching US news headlines, Cracker Barrel's new CEO, David Deno, started yesterday, after a controversial rebranding failed. Most of the commentary says the board took too long to make a change, but I'm not sure that really holds up.

The plan for the rebranding came from the management. The CEO and her team built it and the board approved it. The transformation plan, which included the rebrand, carried $600-700M of capex over three years vs. $3.5B in annual revenue. That approval was not a rubber stamp.

What did Cracker Barrel's board do after the rebrand failed?

Unfortunately, the campaign failed within a week of launching. Take a look at the board timeline following that. Store remodeling paused in September, support center costs were cut in December, the "five pillars" plan was reframed into three in January, capex guidance was reduced four quarters running, and then 26 stores were sold and leased back in July. The CEO change came a week after that, so four quarters rebuilding the plan before anyone decided it was time for a management change. Whatever else that is, it isn't a board sitting still.

FOUR QUARTERS OF BOARD ACTION Rebrand launches Failed within a week Sept Store remodeling paused Dec Support center costs cut Jan Five pillars reframed into three Q1 to Q4 Capex guidance cut four quarters running Jul 26 stores sold and leased back Jul +1wk CEO change For scale: S&P 500 CEO and board turnover. 13% S&P 500 CEO succession rate, projected 0.8 Average new directors per S&P 500 board 9 yrs Average departing CEO tenure. This one had 3. Transformation plan capex, including the rebrand, 600 to 700 million dollars over three years, against 3.5 billion in annual revenue.

Only one person can be accountable in this scenario, and that's the CEO. The board is responsible, and they rallied around the CEO and management team to try to recover the business. Responsibility can be shared where accountability cannot. If the plan itself was wrong from the start, the shake-up shouldn't stop at the person who was accountable for it.

Three years in the seat against an S&P 500 average of nine

I don't have enough information to say what board change is needed; however, last November two proxy advisers said board change was warranted, and a third recommended votes against five directors. Since that time one director left after the vote, no replacement has been named, and the only seat the board changed was the CEO's.

Departing S&P 500 CEOs last year averaged nine years in the seat. This one had three, about two of them spent on a plan the board had signed off. Now look at the other side of the table. Last year the projected CEO succession rate at S&P 500 companies was 13%. Their boards added an average of 0.8 new directors each, appointed the fewest new independent directors since 2016, and two-thirds have mandatory retirement policies.

What a board's approval of a management plan commits it to is part of the board advisory work of HundredEast, the independent advisory firm Marc Spiegel founded in Bangkok.