An established Thai food manufacturer decides for a variety of reasons to bring in a private equity partner, and although they may agree on what the business is worth, once the deal is closed, they may find the biggest challenge is what needs to change to increase the valuation moving forward.

It's not a given that the new owners will retain the existing CEO in their current role. It's not unusual for the two parties to agree on bringing in a new CEO. To be successful, that CEO will require a close working relationship with the founding family, along with balancing the expectations of the new investor, earning the confidence of the people running the plant, and meeting international standards of performance and governance.

A strong export industry with an uneven operating record

The World Bank's July 2026 paper, Thailand as a Global Food Hub, has established that there are more than 10,000 food-processing companies in Thailand. This is a mature industrial base with considerable experience of meeting international demand.

Ministry of Commerce figures show agro-industrial exports of US$23.36 billion in 2024, up 4.1% from 2023. In addition to human-food manufacturing the category also includes pet food and other agricultural processing.

Unfortunately, the productivity figures are not as strong. The Office of Industrial Economics' 2024 report (published in November 2025) recorded a 4.95% decrease in food manufacturing's total factor productivity in 2023, compared with a 0.34% fall across manufacturing as a whole. Food manufacturing had only 0.32% recovery in 2024. The food sample covered 933 establishments, which represents 77.9% of the sector sales measured by the survey.

Grafico a barre orizzontali della crescita della produttività totale dei fattori in Thailandia. Industria alimentare nel 2023, meno 4,95%. Intera industria manifatturiera nel 2023, meno 0,34%. Industria alimentare nel 2024, più 0,32%.

Total factor productivity captures more than output per employee; capital use, market conditions and other factors also affect it. The decline cannot diagnose issues in an individual company, but it does give an investor reason to examine how export growth translates into returns. A manufacturer may have customers and orders while not earning enough from the resources it uses to supply them.

What do a family owner and a PE investor each mean by better performance?

Family businesses are traditionally investing for the next generation; however, a PE investor has its own return requirements and ownership horizon, which may be diametrically opposed. Both may say they want growth, right up until the discussion turns to spending money. Does the company add capacity? Accept less margin to enter a new market? Hold on to the cash for reinvestment, or pay it out as dividends? The answers can vary enormously.

It's worth understanding why the family brought an investor in at all, because the answer to that question will shape everything that follows. Sometimes they are only looking for capital to grow, however, in many cases it's about succession. Sun Life published a survey of Asian family businesses in October and found that 78% of those involved said the next generation was willing to take over, but only 26% had a fully developed succession plan. Where the next generation is not fully willing, 39% cite a lack of preparation or experience.

Grafico a barre orizzontali sulle imprese familiari asiatiche nel 2026. Il 78% degli intervistati di imprese familiari afferma che la generazione successiva è disposta a subentrare. Il 26% delle famiglie ha un piano di successione pienamente definito. Dove la generazione successiva non è pienamente disposta, il 39% indica la mancanza di preparazione o di esperienza.

If the next generation is not prepared to run the plant, the family may be using the investor to increase the valuation for a bigger sale later. That's a perfectly good reason, but it changes the conversation, because then both shareholders want the same thing, and most of the arguments will be about speed in getting there. If the family intends to keep the business and only needed the money, the discussions will be different, and the CEO could get caught up in the middle.

The family's continuing involvement deserves careful discussion and consideration. A founder may hold the trust of customers and suppliers, know how the business survived difficult periods, and understand why employees have stayed with the company. That knowledge has real commercial value. The incoming team needs to establish which relationships support performance, where dependence on individuals creates risk, and how responsibilities will be shared.

If a manager has been given authority, but still believes every consequential decision needs the founder's private approval, then not much has changed. Equally, the founder should not discover a change in responsibilities through an executive telling a long-serving employee that the old way no longer applies. Those conversations belong between the owners and CEO, without putting the employees in the middle.

Those conversations belong between the owners and CEO, without putting the employees in the middle.

Agree the 12-month mandate before day one

For an interim role the most important conversation happens before day one, or at the latest in the first few weeks. Everyone needs to agree on what the 12-month mandate is going to be. What are the shareholders expecting to see by month 12? Which KPIs will they judge it on, and who is allowed to change them six months in? What decision-making authority does the CEO have on his own, what goes to the board, and what needs both shareholders? What does the handover look like?

All of that, including the limits of authority, must be clearly documented, signed off by the family and the investor, and reviewed again every quarter. It sounds bureaucratic, but it will save a lot of difficult discussions later. The latest AlixPartners private equity leadership survey, published in March with 427 responses, found nearly two-thirds of PE firms replace portfolio company CEOs during the holding period. The same survey found the investors putting more weight on top-line growth, AI and acquisitions, while the executives running the companies were more focused on margins, debt and operational risk. With a written mandate in place, that gap is less likely to cost somebody their job.

Due riquadri con dati delle indagini AlixPartners sul private equity. Quasi 2 fondi di private equity su 3 sostituiscono i CEO delle società partecipate durante il periodo di detenzione (2026). Il 64% degli intervistati, tra fondi di private equity e società partecipate, non aveva individuato un successore adatto per CEO, CFO o COO (2018).

One of the challenges in this scenario could be if a founder is seen to be working around the mandate. Being aware of it as soon as it happens is important for me to be able to resolve it prior to it impacting the business. Taking it into a board meeting is not an effective setting to be used as a first step in Thai culture. Once known, I would establish a sit-down with the founder to understand the reasoning behind such a move. As I have been hired by the private equity firm (with the family's approval), I have a joint responsibility to inform them as well. The key point is that I am upfront with the founder if the issue cannot be mitigated. I should not position myself to be in the middle, and the owners may end up having to settle it between themselves.

Understanding Thailand must work in both directions

In some of the businesses I ran, I saw first-hand that the people closest to a problem knew about it well before senior management did. The reason being the reporting relationships made it difficult for the employees to raise it, which hampered the company's ability to correct it.

I have seen managers agree that they need to take more initiative and then hesitate because the issue involves somebody above them. Telling people your door is always open does not solve that. If raising a problem gets an employee into trouble, the next person will think twice before speaking up. It is essential to create both psychological and cultural safety nets to facilitate changing the deep-rooted concept of kreng-jai (เกรงใจ) in organizations. When a problem involves someone senior, the founder and CEO need to stand behind the person who raised it. Employees should not have to choose between respecting the family and telling management what it needs to hear.

The language issue goes beyond translating a board paper. It is possible for a meeting to be conducted in English, for everybody to agree, and for the managers who have to carry out the decision to leave without a clear understanding of what is expected. I would rather see the operating people discuss it in Thai, if that is how they can properly question the decision and explain what they need. Once agreed, the instructions and responsibilities should be written down in both languages. Fluent English should not become a proxy for operating competence.

I once worked in a very large multi-national manufacturing environment, which was extremely technical. When I walked the line for the first time I noticed that all of the work instructions at each assembly station were in English. Nowhere did I see anything written in Thai. And when I interviewed the operators that were manning that line, I asked them if they were able to read English, and the answer was no. The next question was to the supervisors. How did they expect them to perfectly execute the workstation requirements if they don't even have the information in Thai. Several months later, we hired the Shingijutsu Institute. For those of you that are not aware, Shingijutsu was founded by former Toyota engineers who learned the Toyota Production System under Taiichi Ohno. It was their recommendation to make it as foolproof as possible by creating videos of the assembly instructions at each station and to have the work instructions in both English and Thai only for backup for reference.

I have had to push back in the other direction as well. In one PE-owned business where I ran Asia-Pacific, most of the fund's directors had very little exposure to Asia. For some of them I was the first person from the region they had ever worked with. We talked by phone, and I met one of them in person for about five minutes. What they knew about Asia came mostly from the previous CEO, who had spent years shrinking it. When I joined, a consulting firm had almost finished a new global strategy and nobody had talked to the Asia-Pacific team. The new CEO, to his credit, flew me and the regional leadership team to the US, and we spent two and a half days in a room with the consultants so we weren't left behind completely. Changing the owners' view took patience, evidence and a lot of repeated conversations. In the end the plan to shrink Asia was dropped and the region became the best-performing business unit in the company.

An overseas shareholder needs an accurate account of operating conditions, including the constraints on its plan. Local managers need to understand what the investor expects from them. Financial controls, food safety and transparent reporting require consistent standards; introducing them takes an understanding of the people responsible for making them work.

As a dual Thai and American citizen, with more than twenty years working in Asia, I understand these conversations from both sides. I have worked inside Thai operating businesses and at international headquarters, under listed, PE and private ownership. I have learned not to assume that two people who walk out of the same meeting have understood the decision in the same way.

Fluent English should not become a proxy for operating competence.

Establish the economics before prescribing the changes

Performing below expectations could mean a profitable company missing a growth opportunity, an operation with weak margins, or a sound business whose investment case assumed too much and isn't meeting the return on investment that was projected in the business case. Each of those scenarios calls for a different response.

For a food exporter, reported margins need to be tested against what it takes to fulfil each customer's orders. Frequent short runs can tie up a line in changeovers and leave packaging stock and cash committed to one account. A lower-margin order may still be worth accepting if it uses spare capacity and makes a contribution that a blanket overhead allocation obscures. The executive team and commercial leadership collectively need to understand those trade-offs well enough to decide which business to pursue.

Thai Union's 2024 accounts show how differently revenue and profit can move. Sales increased by 1.7%, gross profit by 10.3%, and gross margin rose from 17.1% to 18.5%, all while their SG&A expenses also increased.

Due grafici a barre per Thai Union. Crescita dal 2023 al 2024: vendite più 1,7%, utile lordo più 10,3%. Margine lordo: 17,1% nel 2023 e 18,5% nel 2024.

These results should be used to question the business, rather than borrow another company's margin target. If a factory is performing better but earnings remain weak, where is the gain going? SG&A, fixed/variable overhead and interest costs all need to be examined, along with whether the product and customer mix are generating enough profit to meet the owners' expectations.

Management should demonstrate to the board how the plant's continuous improvement (CI) programs have affected earnings, after accounting for raw material prices and exchange rates, because a good financial result could conceal an operation that has made little progress.

Cash released from inventory needs to be judged against the production schedule and back-order pipeline. Shelf life, supplier availability and customer specifications affect how much stock must be held. The CFO and COO need to agree how much cash can be released without creating a shortage that disrupts production or delays shipments.

Customer terms belong in this discussion as well. In one of the companies I ran, I worked alongside legal to rebuild the contract business process and structure. Previous examples of long-term contracts had exposed critical holes in adjusting for raw material, Forex and logistics cost impacts, as well as unfavorable payment terms. As an exporter, all these conditions need to be accounted for before the business is won, or they potentially become undisclosed risks that could impact the balance sheet later on.

Does a food company CEO need food manufacturing experience?

Not having run a food manufacturing business should not be a barrier to hiring a strong CEO. Learning the products, processes and sectors is part of the job and was part of my operating mandate throughout my career given I was entering each company from other industries.

To bolster my chances of success I spent time with the subject matter experts. In manufacturing, that means Gemba walks on the shop floor, talking to operators and supervisors, and participating in production meetings. I needed to understand how specialists make decisions and which issues required my personal attention.

That knowledge matters when assessing an investment or a production change. An increase in output has consequences for quality, product consistency and customer acceptance. A new ingredient, packaging format or process brings technical and operating requirements that belong alongside the revenue forecast. I saw this first-hand: when we transferred a customer's production from China to Thailand, the account grew from zero to $222 million in annual revenue within two years, and moved from an initial loss into profit as production expanded.

Food safety and quality leaders must have the authority to hold or stop shipments. Examining whether they can exercise that authority under pressure, how concerns reach the executive team and whether they have the resources to do their work needs to be field-tested. An established exporter will already have requirements and controls; the assessment must establish what happens when delivery, production and quality priorities conflict.

I have worked under demanding manufacturing customer requirements. In one assignment, I took over execution of an account recovery plan from an outside consulting team. That required working with technical and operating specialists from both the customer and company side and delivering the required KPIs the customer had laid out.

The loss-making account represented approximately 40% of the plant's revenue. The customer projected the plant would remain on its supplier improvement program for two years, however, we completed all the corrective actions and were released in nine months and were able to retain the account.

The root cause was a breakdown in operating procedures that allowed the controls described above to be bypassed. Defects reached the customer, damaging our reputation and affecting both companies' balance sheets.

Making accountability real inside the business

In one ailing Thai business, we decided to measure how long a customer complaint took to reach the managing director. The conclusion was that it took weeks, and sometimes never arrived. The company had been operating in silos, without any authority delegated beyond the top. Each function dealt with its own part while the customer waited for the company to resolve the whole problem.

We determined that it would require rebuilding the structure around what the business required, not based on the historical family-style structure it had been operating under. It was necessary to evaluate the required roles and lastly assess the employees against those. For those who didn't fit into the new structure we considered other positions wherever possible. There was no headcount reduction target when we started. The outcome of the exercise was determined by the future profitability of the business and improvement in customer delivery and satisfaction. After a decade of losses, the business was profitable within 18 months.

By structuring the process in that way, we were able to maintain objectivity without it becoming personal and allow management and managers to save face when confronted with difficult decisions about their respective departments and employees.

Building incentive plans to foster change in culture is a process I have used successfully in two different companies across multiple geographies. Combining company and individual measures and weighting them by level, with some KPIs between departments shared. A senior manager's reward should reflect the performance of the business they directly manage and can have impact on. Departmental targets should not create opportunities for employees to pass costs or problems on to other colleagues or departments.

After a decade of losses, the business was profitable within 18 months.

Building the permanent team

For a twelve-month mandate, aligning with the board what can be completed during those months and what the permanent team will carry forward is critical to ensuring success. Developing managers, changing customer terms and investing in production capability may run on much longer timetables.

A temporary CEO can become the person who settles every disagreement and interprets each shareholder's expectations. Results may improve while the organization grows dependent on someone who is about to leave. It's important to progressively delegate those responsibilities to the permanent managers, with support, while there is still time to address mistakes.

That is why hiring and succession planning need to be part of both the 12-month and long-term management plan. An AlixPartners survey in 2018 found 64% of PE and portfolio company respondents didn't have suitable successors identified for the CEO, CFO or COO roles, so I'd start building that bench in the first quarter. Recruitment should follow the requirements of the business plan, with existing managers assessed for suitability before deciding whether outside appointments are needed. Long-term employees may hold knowledge and relationships that new recruits will take years to acquire. It also means existing employees should demonstrate readiness or be working towards a development plan to bridge any gaps. This is not to say outside recruitment shouldn't take place. Adding a certain percentage of new hires annually can contribute to creativity, drive and energy for an organization as well as developing innovation and staying fresh against the competition.

At handover, the family and the investor should be looking at the same numbers and reaching one conclusion about where the business stands. If the permanent team can take the next decision without calling me, the year has done its job.

What a family owner and a private equity investor agree on before a new chief executive starts is part of the board advisory work of HundredEast, the independent advisory firm Marc Spiegel founded in Bangkok.