Having done business in China for more than 20 years, I've been following the Evergrande case closely. Hui Ka Yan was sentenced to life on Thursday, along with 56 other people linked to the company, five of them senior executives.
How much did Evergrande overstate its revenue?
In 2020 Evergrande overstated revenue by 69%, and reported a profit of 31.4 billion yuan in a year it actually lost 19.9 billion. The year before that, revenue was overstated by 45%. The mechanism was recognizing property sales before the buildings were finished and handed over.
Recognizing sales before completion at that scale is not a year-end entry made by a few people. It had to be repeated across projects and sites for years.
So how did nobody inside the organization challenge it?
In my experience, information does not automatically travel upward in Chinese companies. Hierarchy, personal relationships and the importance of avoiding loss of face can make challenging a superior extremely difficult. Going over your boss's head to foreign headquarters can be seen as disloyalty, create serious pressure from the local chain of command and effectively end a career.
A hotline on its own is not a control
That is why a hotline alone is not a control, whatever the policy says. The test is whether someone can tell the truth without becoming "the person who told the truth."
None of this is only a China problem. Years ago I took over a business elsewhere in Asia where nobody would tell me anything either. The person who eventually did was my own assistant, and she only did it after I told her I wasn't replacing her, which is what every incoming manager does. What she gave me wasn't a report or a complaint. It was a suggestion about where to look. After that I stopped asking people to come forward, and started asking questions I already half knew the answer to, so that nobody had to be the one who volunteered anything.
The regulators got here first
Most of the commentary this week has been about the auditors, and Douglas Robare put the sharpest version of that question. My answer is that boards need to know whether people can get the truth to the auditors before the hierarchy filters it out. The auditors don't have the ability to see anything beyond what is provided to them.
The regulators got here two years ago. PwC's China arm took a six-month suspension and a 441 million yuan fine in 2024, and in April this year Hong Kong's AFRC added a HK$300 million fine and a six-month restriction, and in April PwC set aside HK$1 billion for Evergrande's minority shareholders. The liquidators have since filed a 57 billion yuan claim. All of that is about the people who checked the numbers. None of it changes who inside the company was in a position to say something first.
Whether the numbers reaching a board match what the operation is doing is one of the questions HundredEast, the independent advisory firm Marc Spiegel founded in Bangkok, takes on in board advisory.